Siège ANEAQ

Report on the Evaluation of Training Programmes – 2021 Session

1 347Total programmes
1 042Public higher education77% of the total
305Private higher education23% of the total

1. Applications by programme type

Breakdown of all applications in the 2021 evaluation round.

Public: 1 042 (77%)Private: 305 (23%)
Programme type Number of programmes
Public 1 042
Private 305
Total 1 347

2. Number of programmes by application type

New applications and renewals in both sectors.

Public higher education

New application: 658Renewal: 384
Application type Number
New application 658
Renewal 384
Total 1042

Private higher education

New application: 255Renewal: 50
Application type Number
New application 255
Renewal 50
Total 305

3. Number of programmes by disciplinary field

Breakdown of applications in science and technology, SJES, LSHA, health and education.

Disciplinary fields Public Private
Science and technology 364 104
SJES 305 131
LSHA 267 23
Health sciences 27 47
Education sciences 79 0
Total 1042 305

Public higher education

Science and technology364
SJES305
LSHA267
Health sciences27
Education sciences79

Private higher education

Science and technology104
SJES131
LSHA23
Health sciences47
Education sciences0

4. Number of programmes by university and institution

All universities and institution categories listed in the report.

Public higher education

UM5 – Rabat137
UIZ – Agadir123
UIT – Kenitra106
UH2 – Casablanca113
UAE – Tetouan73
USMBA – Fez65
UCA – Marrakech75
USMS – Beni Mellal69
UHP – Settat66
UMP – Oujda68
UMI – Meknes58
ENPU57
UCD – El Jadida32
University or institution Number of programmes
UM5 – Rabat 137
UIZ – Agadir 123
UIT – Kenitra 106
UH2 – Casablanca 113
UAE – Tetouan 73
USMBA – Fez 65
UCA – Marrakech 75
USMS – Beni Mellal 69
UHP – Settat 66
UMP – Oujda 68
UMI – Meknes 58
ENPU 57
UCD – El Jadida 32
Total 1042

Private higher education

Private higher education institutions195
Universiapolis – Agadir24
Euromed – Fez20
Private University of Casablanca17
UM6SS11
Mundiapolis11
UIR – Rabat10
Private University of Fez6
Private University for a New Africa4
Abulcasis University3
UM6P3
Private University – Marrakech1
University or institution Number of programmes
Private higher education institutions 195
Universiapolis – Agadir 24
Euromed – Fez 20
Private University of Casablanca 17
UM6SS 11
Mundiapolis 11
UIR – Rabat 10
Private University of Fez 6
Private University for a New Africa 4
Abulcasis University 3
UM6P 3
Private University – Marrakech 1
Total 305

5. Number of programmes by degree

All degree categories recorded: 14 in the public sector and 13 in the private sector.

Public higher education

Master271
Doctorate257
Bachelor163
Specialised Master’s degree100
Engineering degree95
Bachelor’s Degree in Education67
DUT39
Bachelor’s Degree in Fundamental Studies21
MST13
LP7
Two preparatory years for engineering schools3
ENCG degree3
Doctorate in Pharmacy2
Doctorate in Medicine1
Degree Number of programmes
Master 271
Doctorate 257
Bachelor 163
Specialised Master’s degree 100
Engineering degree 95
Bachelor’s Degree in Education 67
DUT 39
Bachelor’s Degree in Fundamental Studies 21
MST 13
LP 7
Two preparatory years for engineering schools 3
ENCG degree 3
Doctorate in Pharmacy 2
Doctorate in Medicine 1
Total 1042

Private higher education

Bachelor (Bac + 4 years)118
2 years after Bac + 345
Engineering degree35
Master14
Specialised Master’s degree20
LP17
Two preparatory years15
3 years after 2 preparatory years14
Bac + 3 years13
Doctoral studies7
Doctorate in Medicine5
Doctorate in Dentistry1
Bac + 5 years1
Degree Number of programmes
Bachelor (Bac + 4 years) 118
2 years after Bac + 3 45
Engineering degree 35
Master 14
Specialised Master’s degree 20
LP 17
Two preparatory years 15
3 years after 2 preparatory years 14
Bac + 3 years 13
Doctoral studies 7
Doctorate in Medicine 5
Doctorate in Dentistry 1
Bac + 5 years 1
Total 305

6. Programme evaluation statistics

Expert assessments, responses and programmes not evaluated in both sectors.

Public higher education

Favourable: 731 (70%)Unfavourable: 91 (9%)No response: 180 (17%)Programmes not evaluated: 40 (4%)
Expert assessment Number of programmes %
Favourable 731 70%
Unfavourable 91 9%
No response 180 17%
Programmes not evaluated 40 4%
Total 1042 100%

Private higher education

Favourable: 262 (86%)Unfavourable: 21 (7%)No response: 19 (6%)Programmes not evaluated: 3 (1%)
Expert assessment Number of programmes %
Favourable 262 86%
Unfavourable 21 7%
No response 19 6%
Programmes not evaluated 3 1%
Total 305 100%

7. General observations

Findings from the 2021 evaluation concerning application files, programme content, resources and partnerships.

The 2021 evaluation round covered 1 347 programmes from universities, institutions not affiliated with universities and private higher education institutions, across various disciplinary fields.

The Bachelor cycle was evaluated for the first time: 163 programmes were submitted by public university institutions and 118 programmes by private institutions.

  1. 1Absence of self-evaluation reports for renewal applications.
  2. 2Failure to comply with certain admission requirements set out in the programme description.
  3. 3Lack of practical work (TP) or tutorials (TD) in certain programmes, even where they are provided for in the accredited descriptions.
  4. 4Mismatch between certain coordinators’ specialisations and the modules they coordinate.
  5. 5Teaching hours for practical work (TP) and tutorials (TD) not specified.
  6. 6Insufficient logistical resources allocated to programmes, particularly classrooms and teaching equipment.
  7. 7Weak socio-economic partnerships or partnerships that do not match programme needs.
  8. 8Absence of partnership agreements, or non-compliance of certain agreements, for programmes requiring them.
  9. 9Underrepresentation of doctoral programmes in medicine and dentistry and Master’s programmes in Science and Technology compared with other programmes.
  10. 10Lack of alignment between programme objectives, module content and the expected competencies.
  11. 11Insufficient qualified teaching staff to launch certain programmes, leading some instructors to teach more than one module per semester.
  12. 12Absence of commitments from external teaching staff.